Did Jesus lose those the Father gave Him?

What can we learn from a moment when Jesus' teaching caused many of His own followers to walk away? Looking more closely at John 6, we explore the difference between attracting a crowd and making disciples, the cost of proclaiming uncomfortable truths, and the security of those who truly belong to Christ.
Welcome back to the Extra Point Podcast. Today is Tuesday, October 27th. Really glad you're listening.
My name is Todd. I'm one of the pastors at First Family Church. Thanks for tuning in today.
I want to remind you as you begin to go ahead and subscribe, follow, share, do all those things and help the Extra Point Podcast continue to get traction. Really glad you're listening today. We want to go back and look at John 6 a little more and ask a few questions, make a few more observations.
That is the point of the Extra Point Podcast. So I want to do that in a few minutes. I want to first answer a question that came in, not necessarily about John 6, but about John.
It appears this listener was engaged and even reading further ahead because they asked this question. Why do you suppose they decided to put the chapter break between John 7 and John 8 in the middle of a sentence? So I'm assuming this reader was reading ahead, looking more into the book. This listener even says, I have checked other versions and many of them just choose to make it two separate sentences.
I wonder what the Greek actually says. And that's his question. I looked into this, thought about it, checked the original, and I think maybe some insight here would be interesting.
I don't know that it's going to matter a ton theologically, to be frank with you, but it is true that the division between John 7 and John 8, it is seemingly in the middle of a sentence. Now, before I address that issue, let me remind you that the chapter breaks are a human addition. From what we know, they generally are attributed to Stephen Langton, who, oh, early 13th century, decided to make the Bible's manuscripts and copies more navigable.
And so you could find your places a little easier, but they weren't inspired. At least the majority of the Bible, these were insertions. And so the question is, you know, why was this insertion in this place? It seems an odd place to do it.
In fact, John 7.53 says this, then each one went to his house. And then John 8.1 says, but Jesus went to the Mount of Olives. So it does sound like one sentence.
I would remind you, however, that in the original manuscripts, in Greek language, these copies of scripture, there was no punctuation. Those were things that the translators and different people had to kind of insert, we'll call it. You had to kind of see where it best fit.
It was kind of left up to their discretion in many ways. And so it is pretty natural to assume this is one sentence, but we can't know that for sure. A little more about the Greek language in this assumed sentence that seems to be the end of one chapter and the beginning of the next.
The beginning of 8.1 does begin with day. It's a conjunction. It's often translated but, or, and, or even now.
Here, of course, in 8.1, they use the word but. But what's happening in this is that it's connecting the actions of Jesus with the preceding statement in a contrasting way. And so I think this may be why in the 13th century, the one who inserted the chapters may have felt this was moving now to a new scene.
So it may have been one sentence. John may have written it that way, but it does begin a new scene or a new thought or a new moment. John 7.53, they all went to their own houses.
And in contrast, Jesus went to the Mount of Olives. So perhaps he sees a new scene taking place. Admittedly, it remains closely connected, but here's what I'd say.
Basically, the chapter division, it may seem a little awkward from a reason here to have any alarm or to think that it's a problem. It does separate two closely connected clauses if it is just one sentence, but the contrast is there between what the people did and where Jesus went. So in that sense, it could make sense.
Either way, this question isn't going to be any type of question that would cause a theological division or even would matter in the sense of the interpretation of scripture. It's just fun to talk about. And I think the reason there may be a division there that does seem awkward to us is simply because the man who did insert the chapters centuries ago felt like a new scene was beginning to take place.
And so that's he put the chapter division. That's my assumption at least. I have no way of knowing that, but it's my conclusion based on what I've read.
Now on to some more insight and application, and maybe even some more questions about John 6. And now let's return to John 6 if we can for a moment where we left off, Sonny, and I want to bring some further insight, maybe even some more questions to the table as we think about the claims of Jesus and even the response of the crowds. I want to explore something that we didn't mention much Sunday. I just made a passing reference to it.
It was regarding church growth and how John 6 is the opposite of that in many ways. And I want to explore that a little more. I want to talk about some things that frankly ought to make every pastor, church leader, team member, volunteer, we ought to stop and think through some of these things.
Because here's the raw data from John 6. Jesus preached a sermon, people left. Lots of people, and he let them go. Now think about that for a moment.
In the first part of John 6, Jesus feeds more than 5,000 people. Man, they're so impressed that they want to make him king. And so by almost every visible measurement, his ministry is experiencing extraordinary momentum.
The crowds are growing. People are excited that the possibilities, probably at least to the disciples, seem endless. But by the end of the chapter, everything has changed.
In fact, John 6, 66 says this, from that moment, many of his disciples turned back and no longer accompanied him. These were people that were called disciples. The only ones left at the very end were 12, and he started with 5,000 plus.
That's quite a turnaround from thousands wanting to crown him king to disciples abandoning him. And the most surprising part, Jesus doesn't chase after them. He doesn't apologize for being too direct.
He doesn't offer a revised version of his teaching that's a little easier to digest. Instead, he just turns to the 12. You remember the end, don't you? And he asks them, you don't want to go away too, do you? It's an interesting question.
I mean, can you imagine a pastor in the 21st century responding to a significant drop in attendance by turning to his remaining leaders, his remaining members, and asking that question, anybody else want to leave? Now, I'm not suggesting that's a good church growth strategy. I'm not saying that at all. It's something to think about and ponder, because I do think Jesus' response raises several important questions, we may even say observations, about what genuine discipleship looks like, what we ought to expect from the ministry of the word, how we should understand the relationship between God's sovereignty and our responsibility.
Just some things to ponder here. So let's explore these for a few moments. Dig with me further.
Hang with me. Let's talk and think through some of these observations, these questions, these wonderings. First of all, just think about this.
It's pretty clear that Jesus was more committed to truth than to keeping a crowd. So let's begin here, because this is actually easy to overlook if we're not careful. The people leaving Jesus in John 6, they weren't necessarily hostile outsiders.
In fact, John calls them disciples. Now, I don't know to what level or degree they were disciples, but they were called disciples. They had followed Jesus, listened to Jesus, and to some degree, they had identified with him in some type of way.
But there is a difference, and we mentioned this Sunday, between following Jesus because of what you hope to receive from him, or on your terms, and following Jesus because of who he actually is, his terms. That's precisely what John 6 exposes. Remember earlier in the chapter, Jesus tells the crowd, you are looking for me, not because you saw the signs, but because you ate the loaves and were filled.
That's verse 26. They simply wanted another meal, but Jesus wanted them to recognize that he was the Messiah. They were interested in his provisions, but not necessarily his person.
And when Jesus began explaining that he was the true bread from heaven, he was the one sent by God, who is God, that eternal life was found exclusively in him, and that no one could come to him and receive this life unless the Father granted it, all their enthusiasm began to evaporate. And here's what strikes me. At that moment, Jesus did not adjust the truth to preserve that enthusiasm.
Now, that doesn't mean that Jesus was indifferent to people. I'd say far from that. He was compassionate toward the crowds.
He wept over Jerusalem. He came to seek and save the lost. Luke tells us that.
But his compassion never required him to compromise. And I think that's important distinction for us, especially as pastors, church leaders. Sometimes we assume that if people are offended by biblical teaching, then something must have gone wrong in the communication, in the teaching.
And certainly sometimes that's true, okay? We can be unnecessarily harsh. We can be insensitive, arrogant, or sometimes just plain unclear. Scripture does tell us to speak the truth in love, and Paul instructs us to let our speech always be gracious.
Paul encourages Timothy to preach the word, and so clarity is assumed. But John 6 reminds us that even when the perfect teacher was communicating the perfect truth, some people did reject it. And so just keep this in mind.
Sometimes the offense isn't in how the truth is communicated. Sometimes the offense is the truth itself. Paul makes a similar point, 1 Corinthians 1, verse 23, when he says that Christ crucified is a stumbling block to the Jews and it's foolishness to Gentiles.
You see, listen, listen very carefully. The gospel confronts human pride. It dismantles self-sufficiency.
It tells us that we cannot save ourselves. That salvation comes exclusively through Jesus Christ. And that is not naturally appealing to autonomous human beings, or at least human beings who think they have autonomy.
So here's a question worth asking. Have we confused making the gospel understandable with making the gospel acceptable? We should work diligently to make the gospel understandable. A thousand times yes.
We should remove unnecessary obstacles, explain unfamiliar terms, answer sincere questions. Yes, we should communicate with patience and clarity, but we cannot make the gospel acceptable by removing the very truths that make it the gospel. Our responsibility—and I speak here to pastors, to church leaders, to a team of elders, to volunteers, to those who teach in Sunday school or who lead small groups—our responsibility, yes, is to make the message clear, not to make the message just comfortable.
So just keep this in mind. It's a first observation to think about. Here's another one, a pondering, a question, an observation.
Jesus Christ's response, it reveals the difference between the visible success and spiritual fruit. So I'm left with this question. How do we measure what's really going on? Now imagine evaluating Jesus's ministry based solely on the numerical trajectory of John 6. If we just took the raw data, so to speak, from a numerical value, we'd probably all say, hey, it's been a tough, tough week.
It's been a tough day. Because at the beginning, thousands were following him. By the end, only a few remained.
So if all they had were the attendance reports, we might conclude that something had gone terribly wrong. But numbers don't tell the whole story. In fact, John tells us something that changes the entire perspective.
In verse 64, Jesus says, there are some among you who don't believe. And then John adds that Jesus knew from the beginning who did not believe and who would betray him. In other words, Jesus wasn't surprised by their departure.
He knew this would happen as he continued to communicate truth clearly, even though it was uncomfortable. And here's what we understand now. The crowds were never the ultimate measurement of his mission's success.
Jesus knew that outward association with him wasn't necessarily the evidence of inward connection to him, of faith in him. It really brings to mind the parable they told in Matthew 13. Some receive the word with immediate joy, but when difficulty or persecution comes because of the word, they fall away.
Others hear the word, but the worries of this age, the deceitfulness of wealth, it chokes it out. In the end, only the good soil produces lasting fruit. Now hear me well on this.
This doesn't mean numbers are irrelevant, because every number represents a person. Every person matters. Yes, Acts repeatedly records, in fact, the numerical growth of the early church.
It's often evidence of the gospel's advance. I'm just simply saying numbers alone cannot tell us whether genuine disciples are actually being made. You see, a crowd can gather around something other than the gospel.
You're aware of that, right? Religious enthusiasm can exist even without regeneration. Visible momentum can't sometimes conceal spiritual shallowness. It's hard to see what's really going on.
And this is why I think John 6 is particularly relevant for churches today, for pastors today, because, yes, we should want people to come. We should remove unnecessary barriers. We should be hospitable, welcoming, intentional about reaching those who don't know Christ in our city, those close to us, those far from us.
But we must never confuse attracting people to a gathering with bringing people to Christ. Those are not necessarily the same thing. And I want to add one more dimension.
Sometimes the faithful preaching of Scripture will actually expose the difference. You see, John 6, 66 doesn't describe people leaving because Jesus stopped performing miracles. Here's what it tells us.
They left in response to His teaching. The Word of God revealed what was already present in their hearts. It exposed them.
That's kind of like Hebrews 4, 12, where it says that Scripture is living and effective. It's powerful. It judges the thoughts and intentions of the heart.
And so I want to make sure we understand something here. The Word doesn't merely inform us. The Word exposes us.
And often the result of that is it then exposes where there is false discipleship, false faith, and where there is genuine faith. Sometimes it exposes that a person's been following Jesus for the wrong reasons, not the right reasons, for reasons that really can't survive the actual claims of Christ. Now, I want to be careful here.
I want to be gracious here. I don't want to automatically assume that this leaving in John 6 is the same as leaving a church. That's not what I'm saying.
There are people who leave churches. They change churches for all kinds of legitimate reasons. Yes, pastors should not use John 6 to justify poor leadership or dismiss valid criticism.
I'm not saying any of that. But when it comes to actual discipleship, following Jesus, that's larger and bigger than perhaps someone who changes churches for a legitimate reason. Numbers alone don't tell us that.
The principle remains. Faithfulness to Christ cannot be measured exclusively by how many people stay. It must also be measured by whether we're faithfully proclaiming the Christ of Scripture and accurately communicating His claims, who He is, and what He's done.
That's a sobering truth for those of us who lead churches, our elders, our pastors, our staff. It's an important truth for everyone who belongs to a church. There's more going on than just what the numerical data shows.
I want to bring a third observation to you, something else to think about. Maybe it breeds a question. But it's this one, lastly, that Jesus' question at the end of the chapter, it shows who truly belongs to Him.
And here's the passage I think gets especially interesting from a theological perspective. I love theology. I love digging in.
So I really am intrigued by this moment of discussion and questioning. You know, in John 6, 37, Jesus says this, everyone the Father gives me will come to me. The one who comes to me, I will never cast out.
So we'll log that for a moment. Then in verse 39, He says that the Father's will is that He should lose none of those given to Him, but He'll raise them up on the last day. So log that.
And then thirdly, let's log this, verse 44. Jesus declares, no one can come to me unless the Father who sent me draws him. So I want to take all those kind of statements we've logged, I want to put them together.
Here's what you have. Everyone the Father gives to the Son will come. Those who come will be received and those who belong to the Son will be raised on the last day.
So that's what those three statements that we've kind of mentally logged say to us. Now compare that with verse 66, which I've read you a couple of times, where many disciples turn back and they no longer follow Jesus. So here's my question.
Here's my pondering. Here's this moment of wondering. Did Jesus lose people the Father had given Him? And the answer is no.
A simple, careful reading of the chapter reveals the answer is no. Here's why. John has already explained that some who appeared to be disciples did not actually believe.
That's verse 64. And so their departure didn't overturn Jesus' promise. It exposed the difference between just a false faith and then genuine faith, and that is a crucial distinction.
It helps us understand something about the doctrine of perseverance. You see, sometimes Christians talk about eternal security as though it means that once someone makes a profession of faith and whatever happens after that is irrelevant. But I don't think that's way John 6 presents salvation and persevering in salvation.
Jesus Christ here doesn't merely promise that genuine believers will have a good beginning. He promises that He will raise them up on the last day. There's a continuity and an assurance in His coming work.
In other words, salvation is not simply an event in the past. It is a divine work that reaches all the way into eternity. The confidence of the believer isn't ultimately grounded in the strength of their grip on Christ.
It's grounded in the strength of Christ's grip on them. That's why John 10 28 says these words by Jesus, I give them eternal life and they will never perish. No one will snatch them out of my hand.
And when you hear that verse and all that John 6 contains as well, we should think about the implications. Because if my salvation ultimately depends upon my ability to keep myself saved, then my confidence will always rise and fall with my spiritual performance. But keeping myself saved, I don't have that ability any more than I do have the ability to make myself saved.
It's all about God's gracious work. And if salvation is God's work from beginning to end, and it is, then my confidence rests upon the faithfulness of the Savior who promised to save me and to keep me. Now that doesn't make perseverance unnecessary.
It makes perseverance the fruit of God's grace. And that's what brings us to Peter's remarkable response to Jesus's question. When Jesus asks whether the 12 want to leave, Peter says, Lord, to whom will we go? You have the words of eternal life.
We have come to believe and know that you are the holy one of God. I love that answer. As I mentioned to you Sunday, it's a beautiful and a plain way to say, you are the Christ.
You are the only one who can save us. We don't know everything yet. We don't understand everything, but we accept what you said.
Where else are we going to go? That's the language of someone who's come to recognize that life is found in Christ alone. And here, Peter speaks for the 12, and yet Jesus Christ immediately reminds him that one of them is a devil, referring, of course, to Judas. This is in verse 70 and 71.
So even among the 12, though Peter thought he was speaking for all of them, there was still one who wasn't in. He was close, but not in. He had outward proximity to Jesus, but he did not have genuine faith.
This is a sobering reminder that being close to the things of Christ is not the same as belonging to Christ. I wonder how many people actually approached Jesus with an unspoken agreement, perhaps like many of those disciples did in that chapter who then eventually left. Something like this.
Jesus, I'll follow you as long as you make my life better. I'll trust you as long as your teaching agrees with my assumptions. I'll identify with you as long as doing so doesn't cost me too much.
But what happens when Jesus contradicts your expectations? What happens when his word confronts something you desperately want to believe, but you know it's wrong? What happens when obedience becomes costly, or when following Christ means surrendering something you spent years defending? You see, that's when the difference between using Jesus and trusting Jesus becomes especially clear. That's when you find out if it's genuine faith or false faith. The crowd in John 6, they wanted bread that would make their immediate lives more comfortable.
Jesus offered himself as the true bread that would give them eternal life. When the crowd realized that receiving the true bread meant embracing Jesus Christ on his terms and may not lead to their immediate benefits any longer, many of them walked away. But like we said earlier, Peter stayed.
And it wasn't because Peter was naturally stronger, wiser, or more spiritually capable. In fact, in all frankness, from the rest of Scripture and the Gospels, we know just how weak Peter actually was at times. He stayed because by God's grace, he had come to recognize something that many of the departing disciples, in fact all the ones who left, had not realized.
There was nowhere else to find eternal life. And that's the question everyone must wrestle with. That's the precipice all humanity reaches at some point.
Are you following Jesus because he gives you what you want or because you've come to believe that he's everything you need? Because when everything else is stripped away, church, listening friend, brother, sister, when everything's stripped away, our preferences, our expectations, our religious accomplishments, even our understanding of everything we think God is doing, there is still one glorious truth upon which we can rest. Jesus Christ is the bread of life. He is the true and living bread.
And if you come to him, he will not cast you out. And if you belong to him, he will raise you up on the last day. Thanks for joining me today on The Extra Point.
I trust it's been beneficial, helpful, and I trust that as you live today, you will find great joy and beauty in the treasure of Jesus Christ, the true and living bread. Thanks for listening to The Extra Point Podcast. To find more content and resources to grow deeper in your relationship with Jesus, go online to firstfamily.church/resources.

